Why This ETF Issuer Will not Contact Dogecoin Amid Solana and XRP Fund Plans

America exchange-traded fund sector has turn into a Doge-eat-Doge world in current weeks, with a number of asset managers clamoring to launch spot Dogecoin ETFs.

However no less than one fund issuer is not hopping into the Doge-pile. For cryptocurrency funding agency Canary Capital, the Shiba Inu-inspired meme coin is all bark and no chew.

Canary Capital CEO Steven McClurg informed Decrypt this week that his agency has no plans to launch a spot Dogecoin ETF, pointing each to the digital foreign money’s limitless provide and lack of utility.

The corporate is one in all a number of issuers engaged in a race to ramp up its crypto-based funding choices following the U.S.’ pivot to a extra digital asset-friendly regime beneath President Donald Trump. Canary has already filed to launch spot funds primarily based round Solana, XRP, Litecoin, and HBAR—however McClurg mentioned the agency gained’t be part of the DOGE ETF fray.

“I’ve a tough time placing [Dogecoin] in an ETF wrapper, as a result of the coin is actually designed to go down in worth and continuously enhance in provide,” McClurg informed Decrypt.

“There is no restricted provide there, so that you’re primarily placing one thing in an ETF wrapper that is designed to go in the direction of zero,” he added.

Dogecoin is the eighth-largest cryptocurrency by market cap, CoinGecko knowledge reveals. It’s buying and selling round a value of $0.25 as of writing time, down by practically half because it climbed to a three-year-high value of $0.48 in December. 

DOGE doesn’t have a agency provide restrict, marking a robust distinction with different cryptocurrencies corresponding to Bitcoin and XRP. Mining on the Dogecoin blockchain yields 10,000 DOGE per block, with mined tokens being added to the ever-expanding general provide.

Granted, there are different chains which have uncapped token provides, together with Solana—one other asset that Canary goals to launch a fund for. However there’s a key distinction in his view: utility.

As a utility token, SOL is used to pay for transactions on the Solana community. The community and its native token are used to commerce standard meme cash corresponding to Official Trump, BONK and Dogwifhat. In the meantime, the token can be used to work together with decentralized purposes, plus a rising array of video games on the community.

Meme cash, by comparability, are famed for his or her lack of utility—and Dogecoin, the unique meme coin that was created as a joke again in 2013, exemplifies that ethos nicely. Whereas die-hard DOGE followers have applied protocols to launch meme cash and collectibles on the chain, much like what’s occurred on Bitcoin, they’re area of interest choices with a restricted person base.

Dogecoin has amassed legions of loyal holders, together with some distinguished ones. Tesla founder Elon Musk is an ardent Dogecoin supporter, and he defended the cryptocurrency’s distinctive tokenomics final November, writing in an X put up: “I believe the flat inflation of Dogecoin, which suggests lowering proportion inflation, is a function, not a bug.”

Inspired by the token’s loyal fanbase, some asset managers have utilized in current weeks to roll out exchange-traded funds that monitor Dogecoin’s value. Bitwise filed final month to launch a Dogecoin-based fund, following the lead of asset managers Osprey and Rex Shares. In the meantime, Grayscale final week launched a Dogecoin Belief, quickly after submitting with federal regulators to transform the fund right into a spot ETF. 

Extra broadly, funding corporations have pumped the fuel on efforts to launch new crypto-based ETFs for U.S. buyers, with issuers submitting to supply funds primarily based on a variety of cryptocurrencies corresponding to XRP, Solana, Official Trump, and Bonk.

The purposes come amid a slew of digital asset regulation and coverage shifts within the U.S., such because the nomination of a brand new, pro-crypto Securities and Change Fee chairman. The SEC has additionally launched a crypto activity pressure, with Commissioner Hester Peirce stating that the regulator has to work out of a “mess” created by the earlier administration.

The tone shift—paired with the approval of spot Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs final yr—has ignited issuers’ hopes that the federal regulators might grant approvals to a slew of crypto-based funding autos within the coming years.

Whereas McClurg justified Canary’s submitting of a Solana ETF attributable to SOL having extra substantial utility than DOGE, he admitted that it wasn’t a key focus for the agency.

“It is like, ‘Hey, nicely, if we’re doing these different ones, we would as nicely soar in and get in on the motion if one thing occurs,’” McClurg informed Decrypt of its SOL ETF submitting.

Edited by Andrew Hayward